Pizza in Hawaiʻi is better than most people expect. The islands’ isolation forces creativity — imported flour meets local ingredients like kalua pork, mac nut pesto, and fresh tropical fruit. The best spots range from certified Neapolitan wood-fired ovens to local joints serving pies you cannot get anywhere on the mainland.

I have eaten my way through pizza menus on all four main islands over the past two decades. This is the short list — the places that justify skipping a plate lunch.

Brick Fire Tavern (Chinatown)

One of the few certified Vera Pizza Napoletana restaurants in Hawaiʻi. The oven runs at 900 degrees and the crust comes out blistered, charred, and chewy in exactly the right way. San Marzano tomatoes, imported buffalo mozzarella, fresh basil — the Margherita is the benchmark. Small space in Chinatown, no reservations, and the wait can stretch past an hour on weekends. Bring patience.

ʻIliʻili Cash & Carry (Kaimuki)

Roman-style al taglio pizza sold by weight. The base is thick, airy, and focaccia-like — a completely different animal from Neapolitan thin crust. Creative toppings rotate daily. The porchetta with salsa verde is the standout, but the potato and rosemary holds its own. Limited hours, and they sell out early. Get there before 6 p.m. on busy nights.

Island Vintage Pizza (Waikiki, Royal Hawaiian Center)

Local-Hawaiian fusion pies in the middle of Waikiki. The kalua pig pizza with pineapple and BBQ sauce works — trust the process. Mac nut pesto replaces basil pesto on several options, and it pairs well with fresh mozzarella and arugula. A solid choice when you want pizza without leaving the resort strip.

Joey’s Kitchen (multiple locations)

Primarily a Filipino-Hawaiian fusion spot, but the pizza program is quietly good. The garlic shrimp pizza — an unexpected collision of two Hawaiʻi food obsessions — is the one to order. Multiple locations on Oahu, with a laid-back family atmosphere.

The Best Ice Cream and Gelato Spots in Hawaiʻi

Read More

Flatbread Company (Paia)

Wood-fired, organic ingredients, clay oven. The “Mopsy” — homemade sausage, caramelized onions, organic mushrooms, herbs — is the go-to order. Flatbread sits right on Paia’s main strip, making it a natural dinner stop on the way back from the Road to Hana. Dinner only. Expect waits of 30-45 minutes during peak season, but the vibe in Paia makes the wait painless.

Pi Artisan Pizzeria (Kihei)

Thin crust, creative topping combos, casual South Maui atmosphere. The truffle mushroom is the sleeper hit — earthy and rich without being heavy. Good beer and wine selection. A reliable weeknight dinner that will not break the budget.

Nuka (Haiku)

Not a pizza restaurant. Nuka is a Japanese-fusion spot in Haiku that happens to run brick-oven pizza specials, and those specials are some of the best pizza on the island. The execution is precise and the toppings lean creative. Check their specials board when you walk in. If pizza is on it, order it.

Outrigger Pizza Company (West Maui)

West Maui’s solid pizza option as the Lahaina area continues to rebuild after the 2023 fire. Straightforward pies with quality ingredients. Good for families and large groups who need a reliable, unfussy dinner.

Pueo’s Osteria (Hilo)

A proper Italian restaurant that takes its pizza as seriously as its pasta. Wood-fired oven, imported flour, and seasonal toppings alongside traditional options. The dining room is small, so reservations are recommended — especially on weekends. If you are spending a day exploring Hilo’s waterfalls and gardens, this is the dinner play.

Kona Brewing Company (Kailua-Kona)

Known for beer first, but the pizza is legitimately good. Thick crust, generous toppings, and everything pairs with a fresh Longboard Lager or Big Wave Golden Ale on tap. The mac and cheese pizza sounds wrong but works — carbs on carbs with enough salt and crunch to justify itself. Open-air brewpub atmosphere, good for families, and a short walk from the Kailua-Kona waterfront.

Village Burger (Waimea/Parker Ranch Center)

A gourmet burger joint that added wood-fired pizzas to the menu. The toppings lean local — grass-fed beef, Big Island mushrooms, fresh herbs. Not the primary draw (the burgers are excellent), but if you are splitting a meal in Waimea, a pizza alongside a burger covers all the bases.

Brick Oven Pizza (Kalaheo)

Open since 1977. Family-owned, old-school, thick crust brushed with garlic butter before the toppings go on. This is not artisan pizza and it does not pretend to be — it is consistent, well-loved, and a straight-up Kauai institution. Locals and visitors have been coming here for nearly 50 years for a reason. The garlic butter crust is the signature. Check whether they have added card payments; they were cash-only for decades.

Pizzetta (Poipu/Koloa)

The upscale option on Kauai. Wood-fired, thin crust, fresh ingredients. The prosciutto and arugula is the safe bet — salty, peppery, simple. Good wine list by Kauai standards, which is a low bar, but Pizzetta clears it comfortably. A strong dinner choice if you are staying in the Poipu resort area.

Kalypso (Hanalei)

A sports bar with surprisingly decent pizza. Not destination-worthy on its own, but if you are in Hanalei after a beach day and craving pizza, Kalypso handles it. Casual atmosphere, cold beer, and a view of the Hanalei mountains from the outdoor seating.

Hawaiian pizza culture has its own conventions, and a few are worth knowing before you order.

Kalua pork as a topping is everywhere — and it is usually good. The smoky, shredded pork pairs naturally with mozzarella and a slightly sweet sauce. If you see it on a menu, give it a shot.

Mac nut pesto replaces basil pesto at many spots. Macadamia nuts grow on the Big Island and Maui, and they make a richer, nuttier pesto that works on pizza as well as the traditional version. Sometimes better.

“Hawaiian pizza” was invented in Canada. Sam Panopoulos, a Greek-Canadian restaurateur, put ham and pineapple on a pizza in Ontario in 1962. Hawaiʻi gets the credit (and the blame), but the islands had nothing to do with it. Real Hawaiian pizza — kalua pork, mac nut pesto, fresh island produce — is a different thing entirely.

Spam shows up on some menus. Hawaiʻi consumes more Spam per capita than any other state, so it was inevitable. Approach with an open mind. Thin-sliced and crisped on a hot pizza, it is closer to a salty cured meat than to what you are picturing from the can.

For a deeper dive into Hawaiian food culture beyond pizza, a guided food tour is one of the best ways to eat your way through an island with local context. Browse Hawaii food tours on Viator for options across all four islands. And if you need a car to reach some of these spots — and you will — Discount Hawaii Car Rental consistently offers the best island rates.